Psychoanalysis: Art, Science, or Ideology edited by James Tyler Carpenter is Volume #1: Issue #4 of the International Journal of Controversial Discussions in book form. It consists of the paper :"Psychoanalysis: Art, Science, or Ideology" by Arnold D. Richards, and with discussions by Daniel S. Benveniste, Sandra Buechler, Sandra E. Cohen, Joseph F. Meyer, .Jon Mills, .Merle Molofsky, Trevor Pederson, Burton N. Seitler, and Joel Weinberger and with introductions by Arnold D. Richards and James Tyler Carpenter. Also included are a book review by Alan Karbelnig with an introduction by Jane S. Hall and a book review by Daniel S. Benveniste.